Probably no suprise that I am with Gibran2 & JoeDirt on this one.
I won't reiterate what they have so
eloquently said already on this thread... I can only add that the "Primacy Of Consciousness" model is the best fit for my rather intensive set of experiences. This is something I came to believe decades ago, and every new day only reinforces my certainty that this is the correct model of reality. Or at the very least, it is the one that lies closest to any Ultimate Truth that may or may not exist.
I have studied nearly all of the religions, but I am not religious.
I have studied most branches of science, but I am not a scientist.
Both of these worldviews require too much faith for me. Too much ignoring of the most relevant and pertinent issues of the human condition in favor of nitpicking seemingly trivial tangents.
I am an experientialist. I cherish
direct experience and the knowledge of how to
repeatedly recreate those experiences. Some people call this path mysticism and label it esoteric. And while I don't mind being thought of as a mystic, there is nothing esoteric about the things I know how to do. Not for me, anyway.
It is like turning on a light. Belief has nothing to do with it. I know how it works. There is not even an inkling of doubt in my mind that when I flip the switch, the light will come on. And if the bulb blows out, or the fusebox needs reseting, I know how to deal with those things too. If someone tells me they don't believe in fuses, it doesn't have the slightest ripple of an effect on my knowledge. If it is convenient, I
could take them and show them the fusebox and teach them how it works... but mostly I don't care.
This is how I feel about Lucid Dreaming, Astral Projection, Cosmic Consciousness, Chi, DMT, and more. These are not mysteries for me. They are sciences. I know how they work, and use them with a high level of skill. Academic Science will catch up eventually.
I had a good friend who insisted that accupuncture wasn't real and that it was either a placebo effect or just pure suggestion. Then I showed him video of a man having open heart surgery with only accupuncture as the anesthetic. He tried to worm it into his conception. Struggled valiantly to debunk the video... but in the end, he had to recognize that his conception of medicine was incomplete. He eventually started seeing an accupuncturist who eventually cured him of some debilitating health issues he had. (I won't get into them, so as not to make the argument about whether those things are curable or not.)
To wrap this up, I will just leave you with something I have noticed in my life:
People are defensive of the things that they are themselves unsure of. They try to prove their belief to another, as a way of proving it (reinforcing it) for
themselves. You don't argue with someone who insists that the sky is a deep forest green. If your 90 year old Grandma insists that you can't video chat with people in 6 locations around the world, and that the internet is fake... you don't press the point. People argue about G*D, or the afterlife, because
they don't know. Most heated debates center around things that people are fundamentally unsure of.
If you know something... you know it.
"Curiouser and curiouser..." ~ Alice
"Do not believe in anything simply because you have heard it. Do not believe in anything simply because it is spoken and rumored by many. Do not believe in anything simply because it is found written in your religious books. Do not believe in anything merely on the authority of your teachers and elders. Do not believe in traditions because they have been handed down for many generations. But after observation and analysis, when you find that anything agrees with reason and is conducive to the good and benefit of one and all, then accept it and live up to it." ~ Buddha