I would just eat it.
the baster was probably polyethylene. xylene softens and expands pe but does not dissolve it.
the "plastic at all" statement isnt quite true, HDPE tolerates xylene pretty well as does nylon, but true enough, xylene is hard on most polymers, but it does not dissolve many.
If you felt obliged to clean it for sure, you would redissolve the mescaline acetate in mildly acidic water, basify to 9.5 or higher, reextract with xylene and then salt out with with your chosen acid water. sure to lose some.
its always nice to go back to the basics... the first bonifide documented with pictures and repeated mescaline extraction from san pedro was nanook's, 2002.
Nan's extractionand then building on that and with nan's help, the first straight to base (2003), using HCl to salt, extraction was mine. I still do it just like my tek despite all of the modifications and advice people have added over the years. I did a big one a few months ago, works great. I do use
square HDPE carboys from usplastics now instead of glass.
foaf's stb tek