I tried adding more base and that seemed to push a little bit out, but I think the unfortunate correct answer is probably more naptha.
I don't think the naptha is lost, I just think you need to do more pulls and you'll eventually get at all the good stuff. I think you probably didn't have your mush dry enough in the beginning. You need to fing the line between mushy and crumbly. When you get this tek down, it's a pleasure.
Don't panic. Everything will work out. Whatever you do, don't despair and throw anything away.
As for storage: If you are leaving the naptha in overnight, leave it at room temp. You don't need to refrigerate your base material. It's not going to rot. If it's in a well ventilated area you can leave the lid off, just cover it with something like a piece of cardboard or a stocking. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but it's not a bad thing if some of that naptha evaps off overnight. That way, when you pour it off, it will be more concentrated and freeze precip better.
Welcome Home Mister_Niles. We've Been Waiting For You.
"Don't worry. When it happens, you won't be able to not let it do its thing. You won't have the ability to distinguish a pen from a hippopotamus"
- Art Van D'lay